Custom Decorated sugar cookies in the heart of rockaway
Savour the taste of mouth-watering goodness with my delectable sugar cookies in Rockaway. Perfect for any occasion, from birthday celebrations to elegant weddings. Trust me to bring sweetness to you, every time.
Featured Cookies
Click on a picture to view each gallery
Holidays
Special Occasions
Birthdays
Corporate Logos
Monthly Cookie Club
Looking for a way to enjoy Alexis Baked A Cookie’s delicious, iced sugar cookies without having to order every month? Then the Monthly Cookie Club is just for you! You’ll get a baker’s dozen (that’s 13!) scrumptious cookies each month you’re a member. The cookie designs will celebrate a fun theme or holiday—such as July’s National Ice Cream Month—so you can enjoy a unique treat that matches the season or special occasion.
Welcome to: alexis baked a cookie
I’m a cottage home based baker who specializes in creating beautiful and delicious custom decorated sugar cookies for all occasions. Whether it be birthdays, corporate events or weddings, I’m here to help you make your event delicious.
Let’s Bake
Ready to order? I’m so happy you considered Alexis Baked A Cookie for your event, party, or gift. Let’s get started on your cookies!
sweet talk
“These cookies are so cute and delicious! They’re such a perfect treat for any party as a dessert or parting gift. Alexis does such a good job with the designs it’s hard to take the first bite and mess it up!”
— Dean C., Rockaway, NJ
“Alexis does an awesome job with the sugar cookies. Each one I ordered was beautifully decorated with care. Delivery was prompt and everything was perfect. Highly recommend anyone with special events to order from Alexis Baked A Cookie. It will add an elegant touch to your event. I believe with all the communion, graduation and showers coming up, these cookies will be a great party gifts for the guests to take home.”
–Julianne W., Green Pond, NJ
“These cookies are not only beautiful but they are DELICIOUS!!!! So fresh and tasty!!!! Highly recommend Alexis baked a cookie! Excellent!!!”
— Cathy B., Brick, NJ
-
Alexis Baked A Cookie Delicious Cookie News April 2026
Happy Spring!! Welcome to the April edition of Delicious Cookie News.
-
Visit to StoneyBrook Elementary School
It was an honor to speak with the students in the Stoneybrook Trep$ program.
😋 Want some sweet emails?
Be the first to be “in the know” by signing up for my newsletter.